Sommeliers Choice Awards 2025 Winners
Winery In Northern New South Wales Continues Fight To Scrap Wine Equalisation Tax
A winery in northern New South Wales says it may cut jobs and ties with the domestic market if the Federal Government`s wine equalization tax (WET) reforms go ahead.
The 2016 budget revealed the cap on the WET rebate will be lowered to $350,000 from July 1, 2017 and then to $290,000 from July 1, 2018.
The reforms will also see tougher eligibility criteria for the rebate which has been welcomed by John Cassegrain, managing director of Cassegrain Wines.
`The good point is that they really have tightened up the ability of what we call `virtual wineries` taking advantage of the WET rebate that really was designed for producers of wine, whether it be grape growers or wine makers,` he said.
It`s going to do two things: it`s going to save quite a few million dollars to the government [in] giving rebates that were not justified.
`Also, it\'s going to take out of the market a lot of wine that is undermining the price structure of the wine industry.`
Medium-sized wineries will feel impact of WET
But Mr Cassegrain said the cap reduction of the rebate would hurt medium-sized producers who were above the $290,000 rebate threshold.
`For most boutique small wineries that are typically operated by the owners and employ very few people, it has no effect on those whatsoever because they`ve never maximised the WET rebate,` he said.
`But for medium-sized companies that employ 15 or 20 people, it`s going to have a serious impact on the profitability of those businesses and the ability of those businesses to continue employing people.
`So it will have a significant impact on Cassegrain Wines and a lot of other long-term family companies, whether it be Tyrrell`s in the Hunter Valley or Brown Brothers.
`First, we`ve got to talk to the government and make sure they understand the implications of what they`ve announced.
`I think this has been done by the Department of Treasury, the Liberal Party, who are a little bit removed from regional and rural Australia and I`m hoping through the National Party we can get our voice heard.
`I guess our alternative is to more focus our growth on exports and maybe walk away from the domestic market or we reduce employees and downscale the winery.`
Scrap WET and replace with volumetric tax
He said the WET should be scrapped altogether and replaced with a sensible volumetric tax.
`If a tax is such that a government has then got to give a rebate to a certain part of the industry, then the whole tax in the first instance is wrong,` Mr Cassegrain said.
`So the whole WET tax is an ill-conceived tax and what would much better suit us is a realistic and internationally competitive tax on wine volume.
`That\'s a hard one to put forward, but I\'m sure that\'s the right way to go.
`Most of our international competitors, wine producing countries, all have a wine tax volume tax, not a tax on alcohol but volume, and I think that\'s what the WET tax should be replaced with.`
Mr Cassegrain said Australia could learn a thing or two from the New Zealand wine industry.
`Over there, they are protecting their high-end industry [and] because they haven`t got a low-end industry, it`s very easy for them,` he said.
`What it means is that their volumetric tax makes cheap Australian wine more expensive comparatively to their higher end wine.
`Australia should take a leaf out of the Kiwis` thinking in this regard.`




